All true.
Positives about him:
We recruited him so there is familiarity.
He has completed only two years of classes. Given that they are likely to be mostly general education classes, he is less likely to lose a lot of credits.
Adding a proven player with pass catching ability to depth is a good thing.
Negatives (potential negatives)
Why is he transferring?
Assuming Noel is back, you now have 3 Juniors, a Senior, a RS Freshman and a True Freshman. How does bringing him in affect Robert’s view of future playing time?
You are now very top heavy at the RB spot where you could potentially lose three of them after 2023 and then you are screwed.
Not against your suggestion, but these are things that you have to look at in terms of roster management.